Sunday, December 30, 2012

The Bitter Pill of Human Milk Banking

Breastfeeding is the root of self-reliance.  It is like the farmer who saves his seeds year after year, not dependent on Monsanto or seed companies for survival.  A woman who breastfeeds without the aids of our breastfeeding technology (such as pumps, special bottle nipples (teats)/bottles, or other gadgets) is independent of our consumer-driven world.  Her infant determines her production, no other interventions or industry can interfere with that relationship.  She is in the economic driver's seat, financially beholden to no company.  Do we think that in our capitalist society that any industry would be satisfied with this kind of situation where the potential consumers, mother and baby, is independent, not needy of the toys and trinkets of this world?

Yes, the world of women, independent of our consumer-driven economy, seems to be unrealistic.  I know the usefulness of an electric pump and other breastfeeding gadgets that sometimes make breastfeeding easier.  Yet I see that the pump to be useful requires extra time for patient education; and without that education it has the potential to sabotage the breastfeeding relationship.  Using bottles of human milk is a step above the use of infant formula, yet it too can sabotage a mother's ability to breastfeed. Like any medical device, it can save ya (and certainly saves many premature babies) but it can create complications.  We often end up with breastmilkfeeding rather than breastfeeding.

I have always supported human milk banking, believing that every hospital that has birthing mothers needs a milk bank.  Why do I write a blog post about human milk banking being a bitter pill?  Quite simply, the game has changed without most breastfeeding advocates understanding that the game-plan has been quietly changed by the powerful influence of the infant formula and pharmaceutical industries.  These industries are often one and the same companies.  They are the invisible hands now involved in human milk banking.  They smell money to be made and the infant formula industry also recognizes that the long range picture of the public's perception of the safety of their product is crumbling.  Preparation for all contingencies is how some industries survive while others die.

I wrote a blog post this summer about the merging interests of the infant formula and human milk bank industries.

http://vwmcclain.blogspot.com/2012/07/the-infant-formula-industry-merges-with.html

There is now more evidence through patent applications that these interests are increasing.  Nestle has made 2 recent infant formula patent applications that suggest that components from human milk are being considered among other mammal milks:  such as bovine, buffalo, horse, or goat.  There is patent application 20120321600 entitled, "Infant Formula with Probiotics and milk fat globule membrane components," invented by Jalil Benyacoub et al.  Or patent application 20120219526 entitled, "Nutrition compositions comprising lactoferrin and probiotics and kits of parts thereof,"  invented by Petra Gerda Klassen et al.  So we wonder where will they get human milk fat or lactoferin? Well, it is interesting that Prolacta Bioscience, has on its Board of Directors, Ernie Strapazon, a former executive of Nestle.  He helped establish Nestle Nutrition in the USA and was President of Nestle, USA.  Although to be fair one of Prolacta's executive managers who is VP of their sales and marketing was employed by Mead Johnson.  And on their scientific advisory board there is Lars A. Hanson, winner of the 2004 Nutricia Foundation award. (Nutricia is a European infant formula company) And, of course there is the Prolacta and Abbott co-promotion agreement.  So Prolacta seems to have a smorgasboard of infant formula companies involved in their welfare or should we say economic survival?  So it may be reasonable to assume that at least here in the USA, the infant formula industry has its fingers in one company that collects donor human milk.  Of course, Nestle has always had its fingers in everything and its applications are non-specific in which mammal component they will use.  I guess it is to keep everyone guessing and wondering.

Of interest to me is the connection between HMBANA donor milk banks, researchers, and the infant formula industry.  I just recently ran across patent #8314061 entitled, "Adiponectin for treatment of various disorders," invented by Ardythe L. Morrow, Lisa J. Martin, and David S. Newburg.  The owners are the Children's Hospital Medical Center of Cincinnati, Ohio and the University of Massachusetts.  I imagine they will try to license this out and may have already done so, since Morrow has in the past received funding from Mead Johnson.  Although she has received alot more funding from the NIH (National Institute of Health).  This patent mentions that donor milk came from the Cincinnati Donor Milk Bank and from Mexico (research done there some years ago).  [Adiponectin is a human milk component--the patent also mentions that this can be of use in baby formulas]

A recent research paper in which Dr. Morrow was involved was funded by Mead Johnson.
http://jn.nutrition.org/content/early/2012/12/11/jn.112.163857.short?rss=1
  
"Cincinnati Children's Hospital is a collection site for the Mothers' Milk Bank of Ohio in Columbus.  The MMBO, which is a service of the Grant Medical Center is a member of the Human Milk Banking Association of North America."
from website of Cincinnati Children's Center for Breastfeeding Medicine

At one web page blog post at Cincinnati Children's they explain milk banking.  They also write about the struggle of the HMBANA milk bank in Columbus to supply human milk to hospitals throughout Ohio.  Dr. Geraghty is quoted, "The milk isn't just for patients at Cincinnati Children's--it is available for use at all local area hospitals."   No mention that milk is used for reseach on this particular web page.  I presume when a potential donor mother signs up, she is thoroughly informed of their research program.  I can't quite envision them mentioning previous patenting on donor milk.  But I am rather concerned that it appears that this advertising for donor milk is not as informative to potential donors as I believe it should be.

So this is to me the bitter bill that human milk banking presents.  It does in fact save NICU babies but some of what women donate goes to research to make a better infant formula or a pharmaceutical.  Many breastfeeding advocates fully support human milk banking without question, and find my stance repugnant and destructive.  I find myself wondering why we don't look into the future ramifications of this new industry.  This research is about human milk not breastfeeding.  Its about using a component in a drug or in baby formula. Do we truly believe that the infant formula or pharmaceutical industries will market these new drugs or formulas without sabotaging breastfeeding?  Have these industries ever, ever played fair in regard to breastfeeding?  How aware are donor mothers about the potential use of their freely given milk?  Yes, some of it goes to infants in need and even adults in need.  But how much of this is going for self-serving economic speculation on the potential of human milk components?  Are mothers really being fully informed?  For me it is a bitter pill, that breastfeeding is so devalued in our society and yet the infant formula and drug companies are busily patenting on it.  Twenty years ago I had a dream of human milk banks in every city.  Now I look at it as a nightmare of capitalism.
Copyright 2012 Valerie W. McClain 

 



 

Sunday, December 16, 2012

Gun violence, women and children in the USA

In the USA the threads of violence seep into every crevice and cranny of our lives.  Those blackened, evil threads impact our minds and our hearts.  We weep for the victims and their families.  Innocence becomes the victim of our violence.  We fear for ourselves and our families.  Will our children/grandchildren die at school because of this madness?  Will that shopping trip be our families last trip?  Will going to the movies be "real" violence in 3D?  You hear a heated conversation, you wonder does this person have a gun?  You read in the paper, "Young mother of three shot execution-style in front of her children ages 3, 2, 1."  They were your neighbors a few years ago.  Small idyllic sea-side town, paradise;  and yet the threads of violence are under our sandy, sunny shores.  We become paralyzed by our fears.

This culture of violence is more often directed at women and children.  The recent horror in Connecticut killed adult women, educators, and young girls and boys of 6 and 7 years of age.  I recently read a statistic about women who die at their workplace.  Statistically, women die in the workplace from gun violence not from a heart attack or job related injury.  Why is this violence directed at women and children?  We are easy targets for an enraged male with a gun who does not discuss disagreements but instead solves problems with the power of a gun.  We congregate in churches, in malls, at schools and are easy pickings for someone with an assault rifle, high on prescription or street drugs.

Listening to the election debates this year and reading headlines was just plain sickening.  Republican males believing that they have the right to decide issues regarding the female body.  Is there any wonder why women do not report rapes, with legislators and judges in court systems who blame the women for her rape.  If she was pure, she wouldn't get raped or have the rapist's baby.  Men without brains running for government offices.  The Republicans wonder why they lost this election.  Simple.  They totally discounted women.  I wonder how many men think the crazy thoughts that were expressed by the Republican candidates during this election.  And we wonder why violence is directed at women and children.  We don't exist to these men of power.  They haven't even figured it out that they lost this election because they have no compassion or understanding of women or children issues.

American culture is war.  We are like the Greek Spartans.  We wage wars across the world with little understanding of other cultures.  Inherent in those wars is what is called by our war machine, collateral damage:  death to civilians who get in the way.  Those civilians are usually women and children.  Wherever armies go, along comes rape and pillaging.  This attitude directed towards other nations seeps into our culture, fermenting a young male attitude about women and children.  It permeates Hollywood movies, with their violence towards women.  The roles women play in the movies being rather bizarre and usually not central to the movie.  And usually women are the "expendable" characters.  The ones butchered, shot or murdered in some horrid way.  How does this impact young men?  Even the gaming is about wars and fighting.  We are steeped in the tea leaves of violence towards others but in particular violence against women.

We wonder why birth and breastfeeding doesn't happen in the USA.  Why are our c-section rates so high?   Why breastfeeding just doesn't work?  Look towards the male views of women in American society.  Look to a political system warped by the power of weapons, the power of a male world outlook on how problems get solved.  Problems are solved through power and force.  Birth and breastfeeding problems are not solved in this manner.  They are solved by community, by women to women sharing, by the tincture of time.  Our violent society has no time for such problem solving.  Birth by the clock or else--we cut you open!  And if breastfeeding doesn't happen right after birth, we solve the problem by sticking a bottle in a baby's mouth.  The violence of surgical births and shoving a bottle or a boob into a baby's mouth is part and  parcel of a society that believes there is no time left to solve problems.  So we solve our problems by force.  And in the case of Friday's tragedy, a young male solves his problems by killing women and children.  We are a sad, sick society.  Those threads of violence are creating the downfall of a country.
Copyright 2012 Valerie W. McClain



 

Monday, December 10, 2012

The Breast: Fear, loathing, and mutilation

Yesterday, a Facebook friend posted a story from Natural News about this year's Miss District of Columbia who planned to have a "preventative" double mastectomy after competing in the Miss America pageant.  This young woman did not have breast cancer.  The source for the story in Natural News was from a blog in the Washington Post.  This young woman's  mother died from breast cancer when she was 16 years old.  According to the Washington Post blog the young woman who is now 24 years old stated, "My dad looked me in the face and said, 'You're going to end up dead just like your mother."

According to the article she does not have the BRCA1 or BRCA2 gene mutations that indicated a high risk for breast cancer.  Some women who carry these mutations have "preventative" mastectomies. But she is a carrier for Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome.  Her doctors "suspect a correlation between the mutation and breast cancer," despite the fact that this immune disorder is mostly found in men.   All the women in her family have died from breast cancer.  I assume this is the reason they suspect that this syndrome predicts that she too will die from breast cancer.

I made a rather ugly comment on Facebook to this article because it hit me hard.  Why?  Because my mother died when I was 14 years old of breast cancer.  And I cannot fathom a father telling his daughter that she was going to end up dead just like her mother.  Thank you Dad, although you are no longer in this world.  Thank you for not making me believe that I was doomed to die like my mother.  My mother died a young 47 years old.  My world as a teenager went from normal to up-side-down rather quickly.  

I am thankful that what happened to my family so many years ago came before genetic testing and this belief in a infallible medical community that can predict death, disease through gene technology.  My mom died in the 1960's.  She had a mastectomy and radiation.  They didn't have chemo back then.  The radiation was bad enough.  She suffered greatly from the treatment.  But as a 14 year old, I never expected her to die.  It was a shock.  And the reality that life is fragile and far too short suddenly became part of who I am.

So I feel a kinship with this young woman because we both at a young, impressionable age suffered the deaths of our mothers.   It's a loss that never, ever really goes away.  Even in childbirth in my 30's, I cried out for my mother.  I wanted her there to hold my hand, to see my babies.  Only in my dreams do we share the wonder of those births.  She didn't breastfeed me.  I feel that loss but I was born into the bottlefeeding world of the 50's.

Has anything changed in the interim of the 50 years since my mother's death?  It seems more women are dying of breast cancer.  And many women with cancer face mastectomies, chemo, and radiation.  But why are some young women so willing to chop off healthy breasts?  Why do we believe that we are helpless in the face of breast cancer?  We believe that prevention is giving our breasts a good dose of radiation.  Yet, our science tells us that breast tissue is very sensitive to radiation, more so than other tissue.  Is mammograms preventative?  Or do they cause more cancers?  If everyone in a family got brain cancer?  Would a person schedule surgery to take out their healthy brain? We'd consider that odd because a brain is a vital body part. Why are we so willing to mutilate breasts?  Do we believe that breasts serve no purpose?  They are just female decorations?

Why do young women of wealthier families get breast implants as graduation gifts?  Why are women so unhappy with their breasts, that they willingly risk surgery and damaging the functioning of their breasts?  Who are we really trying to please?  Is this mutilation any different than our willingness to chop off our breasts to save ourselves from breast cancer?  

Is public disgust of breastfeeding another side of the coin.  Our society cannot bear to see the breast as a functioning organ in the survival of infants.  Instead, our society honors the mythical, sexualized breast of Hugh Hefner's Playboy Palace.  We can view that naked breast and even the nipple but heaven forbid we see a baby at the breast, even when the breast is covered up.  A sexualized breast is acceptable but a working, functioning body part is not.  And if we can't sexualize it, then we really don't need it.  So it becomes easy for young women to believe in our society that breasts can be manipulated and carved into something better.  Women don't need functioning breasts because afterall we have our designer infant formulas. 

So, we women in this society seem to be giving our bodies, our cells, our tissues to science.  A male-dominated science that believes that nature can always be improved.  Of course,  I start to wonder if this young woman will be donating her healthy breast tissue to science after her double mastectomy.  I guess lately I am always thinking about patenting and how breast tissue is a great source of stem cells.  Yes, suspicious soul that I am, I wonder about medical care providers that do surgery on people that want healthy body parts taken off.  

Why in our society are we so crazy, fearful, and full of loathing regarding the female breast?  Why do women accept that mentality and draw within their souls this self-loathing?  Why do we believe that breasts represent female sexuality, when their function is to feed babies?  Is it akin to the view of female feet in China, where the female foot was bound because small feet were viewed as sexually attractive?  We bind our breasts with bras to make our breasts appear attractive.  We surgically enhance them.  We surgically remove healthy breasts.  How far have we come, we liberated women?  Not very far at all.
Copyright 2012 Valerie W. McClain




 





Wednesday, November 14, 2012

Who is surprised by Nestle's gift to WHO???

Like an owl screeching in the dark, I hear the who of WHO.  I am baffled and bemused by the headlines crossing the Virtual from one media blog to another to various breastfeeding organizations.  This is news??  Hm, where has everyone been the last few years and even longer than the last few years?  Other organizations and blogs have recognized that the WHO is getting funding from industry.  But we, breastfeeding advocates are always the last to find this out?  Oh yes, we now have it in black and white, Nestle is gifting the WHO with $150,000 to fight obesity.  How many Kit-Kat bars will that be???

My bafflement by this "news" reported by the breastfeeding community had me scrambling the internet.  Why is this news to everyone??  I really don't get it.  Just a quick scan of the internet and I found various articles discussing WHO and how it had sold out to various industries...some dated in 2009.  In the year 2000, I got the picture pretty fast that some wheeling and dealing had to be going on with WHO and industry.  No, it was not written in black and white but it was pretty damn obvious.  For those skeptics, there is a blog article
written by Jennifer Sass of the NRDC (Natural Resources Defense Council staff) dated in February 2011 and entitled, "ILSI and the World Health Organization hold closed-door meeting on chemical assessment."  She writes, "Why would the World Health Organization (WHO) be co-sponsoring a workshop this past week, in Paris with ILSI?  One that isn't open to the public?"  She explains that ILSI (International Life Sciences Institute) is a global trade organization mainly funded by industry.

There are other articles written over the years about WHO and the pharmaceutical industry.  So I suppose that we are to believe that everyone in the breastfeeding community believed that the WHO somehow was not involved with the infant formula industry in the same way it was involved with the chemical and pharmaceutical industries?  Hm, maybe breastfeeding advocates should take a very hard look at HIV/AIDS policy in the past decade?  Or maybe not, because it can make your heart sink to the floor.

The world right now is being guided and subverted by the needs and wants of that person we call in the US--The Corporation.  Private meeting between government/non-profit organizations and industry spells trouble with a capital "T."   Obviously, things have gotten so blatant that the WHO and Nestle feel that they can make their deals public.  But you know, this isn't news.  It's been brewing for a long time.  And, I would say that the very nature of it being public means that at the very least Nestle feels they are unstoppable.

The key question is how does an organization like the WHO sell out?  How did this evolve?  Is it that our world has become unwilling to allow individuals to ask questions about organizations?  Does funding matter in research and with our representatives in governments?  Why are critics silenced?

We, as a world, need more views, more discussions.  Yet, we are moving towards less discussions and silencing anyone who dares express an alternative view.  How organizations are funded and how our policy makers are funded is important.  Yet our world seems so corrupt that one feels helpless in the face of such unethical behaviors.  Feeling helpless only breeds an apathy that is self-destructive.

So write emails, help make these organizations become aware that their decisions impact you and your family and your country.  Yeah, I am tired of writing and emailing and yeah I am just tired.  But just one more email, eh??  Just one more letter.  Just one more blog post....
Copyright 2012 Valerie W. McClain

PS:
BMJ of February 2007, "Who's funding WHO?"
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1801033/ 

globalhealthpolicy.net
http://www.globalhealthpolicy.net/?p=826


Sunday, November 4, 2012

Chaos and the Butterfly

Many years ago when I was a child, a teacher read to my class, "For the want of a nail the shoe was lost..."  I didn't understand it but we had to memorize it.  So I could say it but I didn't know what it meant nor did I care.  After all, it was just school, where I memorized many things that made no sense to me and forgot most of it anyway.  Of course at my age now a lot of what I learned no longer is considered true or even relevant to this day and age.  Amazing to hear that children, at least in Florida, no longer have to learn cursive.  How many hours I spent writing my letters over and over again.  So much time in fact that I developed a callus on my finger from all that practice.  Now we have computers to do it all.

I was just talking to a college friend the other night and we were lamenting the changing of the world.  So much change we don't recognize this new reality as "our" reality.  No one talks to anyone anymore, we text.  I shouldn't say "we" because I don't text much.  I have been known to take two days to respond to a text message.  Same could be said about my email.  At first I was enthralled by our instantaneous communication devices, but gradually I have come to realize that we have lost more than we have gained by our new technology.  I miss my childhood memories of family gatherings, where stories were told, music played by family members, and dancing.   Instead family gatherings are few and most often filled with individuals peering intently at their cell phones.  Time, who has time?  Conversations seem weird, disjointed.  In fact often I feel like the only discussions are scripted by the Internet.  I have lost my satisfaction in talking and even eating.

Food tastes weird, don't you think?  It doesn't taste like it use to taste, doesn't even look like it use to look.  Am I that time traveler transported by age into a world I find so little appealing.  I am tired of the noise, the smells of our new age.  Maybe it's my age or just tiredness of this world created by corporate greed and hubris.

My friend and I talked about our babies, all grown-up.  And now grandchildren.  And how mothers don't breastfeed anymore, they pump their milk.  Isn't this another aspect of a massive disconnect of human nature?  We make our moms separate from their babies because economic survival is dependent on every adult being employed.  And our babies become part of this massive movement away from human contact towards the blue glow of megabytes and gigabytes.  Breastfeeding is becoming human milk feeding. Everyone writes and talks about them as if they are one and the same thing.  We shower our new mothers with numerous products so that she doesn't have to connect with her child.  We take away time she needs to get to know this new little being.  Time, a treasure that has been usurped by our technology.  Your computer time moves as fast as the speed of light in comparison to the your time spent at the beach.

Human milk has become this commodity to be given, bought, or sold.  It's property but not property of the mother or the child.  But property of some company.  We accept that ownership.  We accept this complete disconnect from mammalian behavior.  We think we can understand and teach breastfeeding with our technology.  Yet that doesn't seem to be happening, at least I don't see it.  We seem to have enticed many women to choose breastfeeding but our technology is not creating a breastfeeding society.

Variation in B minor of "For the want of a nail..."

"For the want of a stem cell, human milk was lost.
 For the want of human milk, breastfeeding was lost.
 For the want of breastfeeding, the baby was lost.
 For the want of a baby, the family was lost.
 For the want of a family, the community was lost.
 For the want of a community, the world was lost.
 And all for the want of a stem cell."

Copyright 2012 Valerie W. McClain

Thursday, September 27, 2012

A salute to "World Milksharing Week" September 24-30


"There is serious concern that some of these artificial recombinant DNA molecules could prove biologically hazardous.  One potential hazard in current experiments derives from the need to use a bacterium like E. coli to clone the recombinant DNA molecules and to amplify their number.  Strains of E. coli commonly reside in the human intestinal tract, and they are capable of exchanging genetic information with other types of bacteria, some of which are pathogenic to man.  Thus, new DNA elements introduced into E. coli might possibly become widely disseminated among human, bacterial, plant, or animal populations with unpredictable effects."
                                                The Paul Berg letter in "Science" 1974

Is this a hint of things to come, the darkening shadows being played out in our science fictionalized world?  Or did the Asilomar Conference in 1975 resolve this situation by letting the scientists themselves self-regulate the dangers of this new science.  Never before had scientists come together and proposed a year long moratorium on research.  But when that year long moratorium ended, did the hazards of genetic engineering subside?  Does self-regulation of such a science create safety or open the door to a variety of dangers.  Those dangers go unrecognized in a society in which the word genetic engineering is considered a dirty word.  Instead we talk about food products that were synthetically produced.  Not saying that dirty word in public means it doesn't exist.  No questions can be asked.  How can you question something that doesn't exist? 

Genetic engineering has its beginnings in the cellular manipulation of pathogens.  E. coli was often the pathogen of choice because it was considered a benign bacterium.  Some guidelines were put in place by the NIH in which some recombinant DNA experiments were prohibited.  But it seems that over time anyone critical of genetic engineering or its direction found themselves out of work.  Not surprising is the fact that industry jumped into this new science, particularly Monsanto.  Genetic engineering had broad applications not only in food technology but in the medical field.  Antibody testing (vaccination, drugs are other products) is one of the products of genetic engineering.  The fast sometimes erroneous results we get regarding the current disease-of-the-month is because our medical testing kits are based on genetic engineering.  Yes, you are positive for MRSA (or it could be HIV or Hepatitis C)...the new testing kit proves without a doubt that you are contagious and very sick.  Wait, two days later you aren't positive for MRSA.  How about your vitamin D levels--test kits are genetically engineered.  Funny, how everyone believes in the infallibility of the test.  They are told they are low in vitamin D.  How do they know this, the test kit tells them so.  Yes it was genetically engineered just for you!  Its always interesting to listen to conversations in doctors offices.  There is something magical about going to the doctor.  Its a religious experience because if the person in the white coat says that you have whatever disease because of test so and so, we believe.  Most of us never question our doctor, and would never consider questioning the test.  Well, your belief is based on the infallibility of genetic engineering, when your blood is tested for diseases.

I have a hard time believing that genetic engineering is infallible.  Or that scientists can self-regulate this science safely.  We are after all human not gods.  We make mistakes, even PhDs.  In fact I would say we learn more by our mistakes.  But our industry and our governments have placed their bets on the side of self-regulation.  The food industry in particular has an enormous impact on our health and well-being as well as our financial state.  Food is a necessity and it takes a big bite out of our budget on a weekly basis.  Infant formula is an expensive product.  Infants who are formula fed do not have immune protection.  They are more likely to get sick and be hospitalized unlike the breastfed infant.  So one needs to factor in not only the fact that the product is costly but it is also medically costly.

The recognition that infant formula is deficient in building immunity has created the need for creating a safer infant formula. Human milk research became the answer to creating a safer infant formula. Genetically engineering  human milk components in bacteria is believed to create a better infant formula. 

A recent patent application entitled, "Biosynthesis of Human Milk Oligosaccharides in Engineered Bacteria,"  by the company Glycosyn LLC has a long list of pathogens in which to create their "synthetic" human milk oligosaccharide.

"The invention described herein details the manipulation of genes and pathways within bacteria such as the enterobacterium Escherichia coli K12 (E. coli) or probiotic bacteria leading to high level synthesis of HMOS. A variety of bacterial species may be used in the oligosaccharide biosynthesis methods, for example Erwinia herbicola (Pantoea agglomerans), Citrobacter freundii, Pantoea citrea, Pectobacterium carotovorum, or Xanthomonas campestris. Bacteria of the genus Bacillus may also be used, including Bacillus subtilis, Bacillus licheniformis, Bacillus coagulans, Bacillus thermophilus, Bacillus laterosporus, Bacillus megaterium, Bacillus mycoides, Bacillus pumilus, Bacillus lentus, Bacillus cereus, and Bacillus circulans. Similarly, bacteria of the genera Lactobacillus and Lactococcus may be modified using the methods of this invention, including but not limited to Lactobacillus acidophilus, Lactobacillus salivarius, Lactobacillus plantarum, Lactobacillus helveticus, Lactobacillus delbrueckii, Lactobacillus rhamnosus, Lactobacillus bulgaricus, Lactobacillus crispatus, Lactobacillus gasseri, Lactobacillus casei, Lactobacillus reuteri, Lactobacillus jensenii, and Lactococcus lactis. Streptococcus thermophiles and Proprionibacterium freudenreichii are also suitable bacterial species for the invention described herein. Also included as part of this invention are strains, modified as described here, from the genera Enterococcus (e.g., Enterococcus faecium and Enterococcus thermophiles), Bifidobacterium (e.g., Bifidobacterium longum, Bifidobacterium infantis, and Bifidobacterium bifidum), Sporolactobacillus spp., Micromomospora spp., Micrococcus spp., Rhodococcus spp., and Pseudomonas (e.g., Pseudomonas fluorescens and Pseudomonas aeruginosa). Bacteria comprising the characteristics described herein are cultured in the presence of lactose, and a fucosylated oligosaccharide is retrieved, either from the bacterium itself or from a culture supernatant of the bacterium. The fucosylated oligosaccharide is purified for use in therapeutic or nutritional products, or the bacteria are used directly in such products."





Pick a bacteria, any bacteria and we will create a human milk component that will make infant formula safer.  I noticed one of the bacterium listed is Bacillus cereus, a well known food poison.  So you and I must trust that using these pathogens is safe and the toxins that would normally be produced have been disabled.  This process of making human milk oligosaccharides in bacteria is not new.  I found a paper written in Glycobiology in 2002 entitled, "A new fermentation process allows large-scale production of human milk oligosaccharides by metabolically engineered bacteria."  So the process has been known for over a decade but I am wonder about how much studying has been done on the safety of this in regard to infant formula.   And then I wonder about this company, Glycosyn, that is based in Massachusetts whose advisory board includes some well known human milk researchers, David S. Newburg (who is on the editorial board of Breastfeeding Medicine and was on the HMBANA advisory board for almost a decade) and Ardythe L. Morrow.   Human milk research is connected to the infant formula industry because we seem to be obligated to use human milk components as the gold standard in which to create a better infant formula.  This science is using genetic engineering to create these substances for the infant formula industry.  




  
This week we celebrate World Milksharing Week.  I  salute the women who donate their milk.  They donate to help mothers feed their babies.  They help babies survive because of the wondrous properties of human milk.  My only wish would be that these mothers understand that some of their donations are about helping the infant formula industry make a better infant formula.  And maybe that is a good thing.  And then maybe it is not a good thing. My fear has been that we don't have a long-term safety record of this technology we are employing to create imitation human milk components.  Breastfeeding has a long-term track record.  It saved babies for thousands of years.  Designing baby milks based on human milk is a complement to the value of human milk.  After all it is considered the gold standard.  But fermenting and genetically manipulating bacteria to create our "synthetic" human milk components creates enormous questions of safety in my mind.  Why are we so willing to genetically engineer human milk rather than work to create a society that promotes and protects breastfeeding?
Copyright 2012 Valerie W. McClain